How to check if a journal is predatory — Beall's List guide
Short answer
Beall's List catalogs potentially predatory journals and publishers. While the original was taken offline in 2017, updated mirrors are maintained by the community. To check a journal: search Beall's List mirrors, verify DOAJ listing, check the journal in Scopus/Web of Science, and use the Think Check Submit checklist. LancetClaw automates these checks.
Execution Steps
- 1Search Beall's List mirrors (beallslist.net or similar community-maintained copies).
- 2If listed, the journal is potentially predatory — proceed with extreme caution.
- 3If not listed, check DOAJ, Scopus, and Web of Science indexing.
- 4Apply the Think Check Submit checklist (thinkchecksubmit.org).
- 5Use LancetClaw predatory journal checker for automated assessment.
Prompt Template
Is [journal name / ISSN] listed on Beall's List? Also check DOAJ status, Scopus indexing, and any red flags for predatory publishing.
Common Failure Points
- Relying only on Beall's List (it is not comprehensive and may have false positives)
- Assuming DOAJ listing guarantees quality (journals have been removed from DOAJ)
- Not checking publisher-level listings (a predatory publisher may have many journal titles)
FAQ
Composite User Feedback
Systematic Review Author
"The step-by-step guides helped me verify all citations and choose the right quality assessment tools."
Research Integrity Officer
"The retraction checking guides are essential reading for every researcher at our institution."
Medical Librarian
"These answer pages link directly to tools and workflows — actionable, not just informational."