What is the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale?
Short answer
The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) is a quality assessment tool for non-randomised studies (cohort and case-control) used in systematic reviews. It scores studies on a star system across three domains: selection (4 stars max), comparability (2 stars max), and outcome/exposure (3 stars max) for a maximum of 9 stars. Scores of 7+ are generally considered high quality.
Execution Steps
- 1Determine if your study is a cohort or case-control design (NOS has separate scales).
- 2Score the selection domain: representativeness, selection of controls, ascertainment of exposure.
- 3Score the comparability domain: comparability of cohorts based on design or analysis.
- 4Score the outcome domain: assessment of outcome, length and adequacy of follow-up.
- 5Sum the stars for an overall quality score (max 9).
Prompt Template
Help me score this cohort study using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. The study examined [exposure] and [outcome] in [population] over [time period].
Common Failure Points
- Using the cohort scale for case-control studies (or vice versa)
- Not pre-specifying which confounders to assess in the comparability domain
- Treating the star count as an absolute quality measure without considering domain-specific patterns
FAQ
Composite User Feedback
Systematic Review Author
"The step-by-step guides helped me verify all citations and choose the right quality assessment tools."
Research Integrity Officer
"The retraction checking guides are essential reading for every researcher at our institution."
Medical Librarian
"These answer pages link directly to tools and workflows — actionable, not just informational."